2000
Pennsylvania
Jillian
Parry
1st Runner Up - Texas
Nicole O'Brian
2nd Runner Up - Kentucky
Kristen Johnson
2001
Missouri
Marissa
Whitley
1st Runner Up - New York
Gloria Almonte
2nd Runner Up - Massachusetts
Marianna Zaslavsky
3rd Runner Up - Texas
Katherine Perello
4th Runner Up - Indiana
Jillian Dornbush
2002
2003
Wisconsin
Vanessa
Semrow
Oregon
Tami
Farrell
Louisiana
Shelly
Hennig
2004
Ohio
Allie
LaForce
2005
Montana
Katie
Blair
2006
Colorado
Hillary
Cruz
2007
2008
Arkansas
Stevi Perry
Tennessee
Stormi Henley
2009
1st Runner Up - California
Jennifer Morgan
2nd Runner Up - Kentucky
Tara Conner
3rd Runner Up - Maryland
Michelle Attai
4th Runner Up - Georgia
Kimberly Ann Harlan
1st Runner Up - Tennessee
Alicia Selby
2nd Runner Up - Michigan
Alicia Jaros
3rd Runner Up - Massachusetts
Jacqueline Bruno
4th Runner Up - New Jersey
Jacklyn Pezzotta
1st Runner Up - Hawaii
Sonya Balmores
2nd Runner Up - Nevada
Helen Salas
3rd Runner Up - Maryland
Amanda Williams
4th Runner Up - Tennessee
Tiffany Stroud
1st Runner Up - Michigan
Catherine Laurion
2nd Runner Up - West Viginia
Andrea Turner
3rd Runner Up - Illinois
Kelly Cruse
4th Runner Up - California
Stephanie Brink
1st Runner Up - North Carolina
Melissa Lingafelt
2nd Runner Up - North Dakota
Katie Cooper
3rd Runner Up - Virginia
Samantha Casey
4th Runner Up - Georgia
Brittany Sharp
1st Runner Up - New Jersey
Alyssa Campanella
2nd Runner Up - North Carolina
Kaitlin Noble
3rd Runner Up - South Carolina
Lauren Caitlin Upton
4th Runner Up - West Virginia
Chelsea Welch
1st Runner Up - South Carolina
Brittany Pjetraj
2nd Runner Up - North Carolina
Julia Dalton
3rd Runner Up - Louisiana
Lindsey Evans
4th Runner Up - Idaho
Shareece Pfeiffer
NOTE
In the Miss Teen USA of the 2000's, they changed the crown in 2003 and brought back the old tradition of 4 runners up in 2002.
1st Runner Up - Georgia
Brooke Fletcher
2nd Runner Up - California
Chelsea Lauren Gilligan
3rd Runner Up - Maryland
Kasey Staniszewski
4th Runner Up - Louisiana
Brittany Guidry